Options for Fiscal Consolidation in the United Kingdom
IMF Working Papers, March 1, 2006
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Options for Fiscal Consolidation in the United Kingdom
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Dennis P Botman, Keiko Honjo
- Published: March 1, 2006
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9781451863499.001
Executive summary
- Uses the IMF’s Global Fiscal Model to examine macroeconomic effects of different timing and composition of fiscal adjustment in the United Kingdom.
- Key high-level conclusions:
- Early consolidation dampens aggregate demand in the short term, but increases output in the long term as smaller primary surpluses are needed because of lower interest payments.
- Reducing government transfers or current government spending yields larger gains than increasing taxes, particularly compared to raising corporate or personal income taxes.
- Conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations.
- A reduction in global saving would make early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives.
- Tax reform aimed at increasing incentives to save could support fiscal consolidation measures.
Findings on timing of consolidation
- Early consolidation effects:
- Short term: dampens aggregate demand.
- Long term: increases output via reduced requirement for large primary surpluses because of lower interest payments.
- Interaction with global conditions:
- A reduction in global saving would make early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives.
Findings on composition of consolidation
- Relative effectiveness of instruments:
- Reducing government transfers provides larger gains than increasing taxes.
- Reducing current government spending provides larger gains than increasing taxes.
- Increasing corporate or personal income taxes is less effective compared to reductions in transfers or current spending.
- Tax reform:
- Reform aimed at increasing incentives to save could provide support to fiscal consolidation measures.
Robustness and modeling
- Results are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations as tested within the IMF’s Global Fiscal Model.
Policy implications and recommendations
- Prioritize composition: favor reductions in government transfers and current government spending over increases in corporate or personal income taxes to achieve larger macroeconomic gains.
- Consider timing trade-offs: weigh short-term demand dampening from early consolidation against long-term output gains through lower interest payments and smaller required primary surpluses.
- Monitor global saving conditions: if global saving declines, accelerate consolidation efforts to mitigate cyclical and long-term risks.
- Complement consolidation with tax reform: design tax reforms that increase incentives to save to bolster consolidation strategies.